Incumbent Mayor Running Third as Mike Judge Takes Commanding Lead in Early Simi Valley Results

Incumbent Mayor Running Third as Mike Judge Takes Commanding Lead in Early Simi Valley Results

Mike Judge leads Simi Valley's mayoral race with 42% of early votes. Current Mayor Dee Dee Cavanaugh trails in third place. District 1 race separated by just 23 votes.

Incumbent Mayor Running Third as Mike Judge Takes Commanding Lead in Early Simi Valley Results

Early returns show a long-time City Council member ahead in the mayoral race while a District 1 seat could be decided by fewer than two dozen votes.

(CLAIR | Simi Valley, CA) — Mike Judge holds a commanding lead in the race for mayor with 42% of early votes, leaving the city's current mayor trailing in third place as thousands of ballots remain uncounted.

Judge, who has served on the City Council since 2010, received 13,447 votes in early results released by the Ventura County Clerk-Recorder's office on Nov. 5. Kareem Jubran, a current Simi Valley Unified School District trustee, ran second with 10,272 votes. Mayor Dee Dee Cavanaugh placed third with 6,616 votes, nearly 7,000 votes behind Judge.

Wayne Hampton Holland III received 786 votes and Robert Clarizio earned 603 votes. The race drew 31,724 votes in early returns.

Judge retired from the Los Angeles Police Department in 2021 after 31 years, most of it spent in the northwest San Fernando Valley. He previously served in the U.S. Army and the California Army National Guard. He has served as mayor pro tem five times since joining the council.

The outcome in District 1 remains wide open. Jill A. Abele leads incumbent Joseph D. Ayala by just 23 votes out of more than 8,300 cast. Abele received 3,141 votes to Ayala's 3,118. Anthony Thompson took 1,396 votes and Todd Taylor received 649.

The margin is narrow enough that the race will likely shift as more ballots are processed. Countywide, the clerk's office estimated that 161,115 ballots remained unprocessed as of Nov. 5, with another 694 challenged ballots in the signature-cure process.

In District 2, Sam Cohen led Richard Perini with 57% of the vote. Cohen received 4,065 votes to Perini's 3,055.

District 4 showed a closer three-way race. Ivana Christmann led with 3,485 votes, followed by Josh Gray with 2,565 and Debra K. Dickerson with 2,237. Gray previously served as a director for the Rancho Simi Recreation and Park District. Scott Juceam received 772 votes.

Measure A, which would raise the hotel tax from 10% to 12%, drew strong support in early returns. The measure received 22,836 yes votes to 9,119 no votes, a margin of more than 71%. The tax applies only to visitors staying in hotels and other short-term lodging. The city estimates the increase would generate $400,000 annually for public safety and street maintenance.

In the Simi Valley Unified School District, incumbent Stephen "P" Pietrolungo led James Greenfield in Trustee Area D with 56% of the vote. Pietrolungo received 3,182 votes to Greenfield's 2,473.

Ryan Rosuck led Jodi C. Lewis in Trustee Area E by a similar margin. Rosuck took 3,236 votes to Lewis's 2,489, earning 56.5% support.

Dawn Smollen, a current SVUSD trustee whose term expires this year, led the race for Division 2 of the Rancho Simi Recreation and Park District. Smollen received 3,611 votes to Mary Northrup's 2,640.

Countywide turnout stood at 39.6% as of Nov. 5. The clerk's office reported 208,228 ballots cast out of 525,136 registered voters. The next update is expected by 5 p.m. Friday, Nov. 6. Results will not be final until the county certifies them.

The large number of unprocessed ballots means races remain subject to change. The District 1 margin of 23 votes is especially vulnerable to shifts as mail ballots and provisional ballots are counted in the coming days.